Congoleum Asbestos Insurance Trial Begins

Newark, NJ, August 3—Congoleum had no choice but to declare bankruptcy under the weight of lawsuits from people saying they became ill after being exposed to asbestos in the flooring, its attorneys said in an article in the Newark, Star-Ledger. And Congoleum's insurers should be required to cover tens of thousands of outstanding claims that could reach roughly a half-billion dollars, they said. But a collection of those insurance companies say Congoleum is trying to shirk its financial responsibilities and cut a deal, without proper input from them, that makes it too easy for people with minor injuries to collect. So went opening arguments yesterday in a trial that is viewed as an important test of how the courts are coping with asbestos-related lawsuits. A flood of such cases have crippled the nation's courts and confounded Congress, which has been unable to craft a solution. "This is a case about the status of the state of the asbestos tort system," said Jerome Randolph, a lawyer representing Congoleum. The trial opened yesterday in state Superior Court in New Brunswick to a standing-room-only crowd where lawyers and spectators filled the benches and even the jury box. Proceedings could last into the fall and will feature a parade of witnesses, possibly including some high-profile lawyers who represent asbestos victims. It will be decided by Judge Nicholas Stroumtsos, not a jury. The outcome will also have an effect on whether Congoleum, which employs about 500 people, can resolve its pending bankruptcy before a federal judge in Trenton. The money the company is seeking from the insurers is central to a plan to form a trust fund to pay for asbestos claims. The case pits Congoleum against insurance companies such as Travelers Casualty and Surety Company, and Wausau. Congoleum's lawyers said the company has increasingly become a target of asbestos claims since larger manufacturers declared bankruptcy. About 70,000 cases have been filed. Lawyers said the company tried to defend the claims, but its arguments that the asbestos exposure from the tiles was limited didn't work. Instead, it decided to settle cases -- even ones where the injuries were questionable. Eventually, the insurance companies said Congoleum had exhausted its policies, and they refused to pay for the defense or settlement of claims, company lawyers argued. By 2003, company officials felt bankruptcy was the only option. "(It) offered a viable chance to survive the asbestos crisis," said another company lawyer Russell Hewit. Lawyers for the insurance companies, however, said Congoleum's actions are not so innocent. They argued the $500 million settlement that is part of the bankruptcy package is unwarranted. Defending claims and settling others has been a successful strategy and didn't require such a large settlement fund, said Barry Ostrager, who represents Travelers. Up to 2002, the company had only paid out $13.5 million in asbestos settlements. Congoleum didn't negotiate the settlement in good faith, he added. It agreed to pay claims that were backed by doctors whose diagnoses have been questioned by a federal judge in Texas. He said the company colluded with lawyers representing victims, including some who are the subject of a federal investigation, to stick the insurers with the tab. "This is a remarkably conflict-ridden arrangement," he said. "The negotiations took place in secret ... to structure the deal."

Other Archived Articles

Housing Markets Improving at a Gradual Pace   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 6, 2014 -- Markets in 59 of the approximately 350 metro areas nationwide returned to or exceeded their last normal levels of economic and housing activity in the third quarter.

Planned Job Cuts Surge in October   Full Article
Chicago, IL, Nov. 6, 2014 -- Planned job cuts jumped 68% in October to the second-highest total this year, according to outplacement consultancy Challenger, Gray & Christmas.

Initial Jobless Claims Fall Again   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 6, 2014 -- Initial claims for unemployment benefits fell by 10,000 to 278,000 in the week ended Nov. 1, the Labor Department said

Grosser Named Tile Person of Year   Full Article
San Antonio, TX, Nov. 6, 2014 -- Tile Council of North America presented its Tile Person of the Year award to Donato Grosser at the Total Solutions Plus event.

NWFA Renews Agreement With Wildlife Fund   Full Article
St. Louis, MO, Nov. 6, 2014 -- The National Wood Flooring Association said it has renewed its Memorandum of Understanding with the World Wildlife Fund.

Tarkett Hosts Second Sustainability Summit   Full Article
Chagrin Falls, OH, Nov. 6, 2014 -- Tarkett recently hosted its second annual Sustainability Summit in Cleveland, Ohio.

Gerflor Acquires Connor Sport Court   Full Article
Chicago, IL, Nov. 5, 2014 -- Gerflor said it has acquired Connor Sport Court of Amasa, Michigan.

Armstrong Illinois Plant Wins Sustainability Award   Full Article
Lancaster, PA, Nov. 5, 2014 -- Armstrong Flooring said its Kankakee, Illinois manufacturing facility has received the 2014 Illinois Governor’s Sustainability Award.

Services Sector Continues To Grow in October   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 5, 2014 -- The services sector of the economy continued to expand in October but at a slower pace, according to the Institute for Supply Management.

Mortgage Applications Fall Last Week   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 5, 2014 -- Mortgage application volume fell last week as interest rates increased, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association.

Businesses Add 230,000 Jobs in October   Full Article
Roseland, NJ, Nov. 5, 2014 -- Private employers added 230,000 jobs in October, payroll processor ADP said.

Earthwerks Names Head of Product Development   Full Article
Houston, TX, Nov. 5, 2014 -- Earthwerks has named Lindsey Nisbet head of product development and marketing strategy.

Linron Names de Beaumont VP Business Development   Full Article
Houston, TX, Nov. 5, 2014 -- Linron Co. has named Gilles de Beaumont, vice president of business development.

Domotex Asia Anticipates Larger Wood, Laminate Area   Full Article
Shanghai, China, Nov. 4, 2014 -- It will require four dedicated halls to house just the wood and laminate exhibitions at Domotex asia/Chinafloor’s 17th annual flooring show March 24-26 in Shanghai, organizers said.

Factory Orders Decline in September   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 4, 2014 -- New orders for manufactured goods fell for second straight month in September on softness in the aircraft sector.

Lexmark Names Wellman Director of Architecture, Design   Full Article
Dalton, GA, Nov. 4, 2014 -- Lexmark Carpet said that Jennifer Wellman has been named director of architecture and design solutions.

Shaw's Tuftex Wins Cool Planet Award   Full Article
Dalton, GA, Nov. 4, 2014 -- Shaw’s Tuftex Division won the 2014 Cool Planet Award, which recognizes Southern California Edison business customers for demonstrating exemplary leadership in energy and carbon management.

Q.E.P. Completes Acquisition of Flooring Trade Supplies   Full Article
Boca Raton, FL, Nov. 4, 2014 -- Q.E.P. said that it has completed the acquisition of Flooring Trade Supplies, an accessory distributor in Sydney, New South Wales.

Stifel Nicolaus Praises Mohawk's Performance   Full Article
New York, NY, Nov. 3, 2014 -- Analyst Stifel Nicolaus says it continues to recommend the stock of Mohawk Industries with a "buy" rating as Mohawk "continues to execute in a very impressive manner given the slower demand environment across the globe."

Manufacturing Expands at Faster Pace in October   Full Article
Tempe, AZ, Nov. 3, 2014 -- U.S. manufacturers expanded at a faster rate in October, according to the Institute for Supply Management.