Congoleum Asbestos Insurance Trial Begins

Newark, NJ, August 3—Congoleum had no choice but to declare bankruptcy under the weight of lawsuits from people saying they became ill after being exposed to asbestos in the flooring, its attorneys said in an article in the Newark, Star-Ledger. And Congoleum's insurers should be required to cover tens of thousands of outstanding claims that could reach roughly a half-billion dollars, they said. But a collection of those insurance companies say Congoleum is trying to shirk its financial responsibilities and cut a deal, without proper input from them, that makes it too easy for people with minor injuries to collect. So went opening arguments yesterday in a trial that is viewed as an important test of how the courts are coping with asbestos-related lawsuits. A flood of such cases have crippled the nation's courts and confounded Congress, which has been unable to craft a solution. "This is a case about the status of the state of the asbestos tort system," said Jerome Randolph, a lawyer representing Congoleum. The trial opened yesterday in state Superior Court in New Brunswick to a standing-room-only crowd where lawyers and spectators filled the benches and even the jury box. Proceedings could last into the fall and will feature a parade of witnesses, possibly including some high-profile lawyers who represent asbestos victims. It will be decided by Judge Nicholas Stroumtsos, not a jury. The outcome will also have an effect on whether Congoleum, which employs about 500 people, can resolve its pending bankruptcy before a federal judge in Trenton. The money the company is seeking from the insurers is central to a plan to form a trust fund to pay for asbestos claims. The case pits Congoleum against insurance companies such as Travelers Casualty and Surety Company, and Wausau. Congoleum's lawyers said the company has increasingly become a target of asbestos claims since larger manufacturers declared bankruptcy. About 70,000 cases have been filed. Lawyers said the company tried to defend the claims, but its arguments that the asbestos exposure from the tiles was limited didn't work. Instead, it decided to settle cases -- even ones where the injuries were questionable. Eventually, the insurance companies said Congoleum had exhausted its policies, and they refused to pay for the defense or settlement of claims, company lawyers argued. By 2003, company officials felt bankruptcy was the only option. "(It) offered a viable chance to survive the asbestos crisis," said another company lawyer Russell Hewit. Lawyers for the insurance companies, however, said Congoleum's actions are not so innocent. They argued the $500 million settlement that is part of the bankruptcy package is unwarranted. Defending claims and settling others has been a successful strategy and didn't require such a large settlement fund, said Barry Ostrager, who represents Travelers. Up to 2002, the company had only paid out $13.5 million in asbestos settlements. Congoleum didn't negotiate the settlement in good faith, he added. It agreed to pay claims that were backed by doctors whose diagnoses have been questioned by a federal judge in Texas. He said the company colluded with lawyers representing victims, including some who are the subject of a federal investigation, to stick the insurers with the tab. "This is a remarkably conflict-ridden arrangement," he said. "The negotiations took place in secret ... to structure the deal."

Other Archived Articles

NAFCD Releases Executive Trends Index   Full Article
Chicago, IL, July 17, 2014 -- The North American Association of Floor Covering Distributors said it has released its Q2 Quarterly Executive Trends Index.

Initial Jobless Claims Fall Again   Full Article
Washington, DC, July 17, 2014 -- Initial claims for unemployment benefits hit the lowest level in nine weeks, according to the Labor Department.

Metroflor Forms Sales Team for Aspecta Brand   Full Article
Norwalk, CT, July 17, 2014 -- Metroflor Corp. said it has established a network of specification representatives for its contract LVT brand, Aspecta Plank & Tile, which debuted at NeoCon last month.

Housing Starts, Permits, Fall in June   Full Article
Washington, DC, July 17, 2014 -- Housing starts fell unexpectedly in June to a nine-month low, according to the Commerce Department.

Summit International Names Sales Director   Full Article
Florham Park, NJ, July 17, 2014 -- Summit International Flooring said that Marc Becker has been promoted to national sales director.

Foreclosure Activity Hits Eight-Year Low   Full Article
Irvine, CA, July 17, 2014 -- Foreclosure activity hits its lowest level in eight years in June, according to tracking firm RealtyTrac.

Contract Furnishings Mart Opens 11th Location   Full Article
Beaverton, OR, July 17, 2014 -- Contract Furnishings Mart has opened its 11th Northwest location in Beaverton.

Producer Prices in June Rise More Than Expected   Full Article
Washington, DC, July 16, 2014 -- U.S. producer prices rose more than expected in June, according to the Labor Department.

Builder Confidence Grows in July   Full Article
Washington, DC, July 16, 2014 -- Builder confidence in the market for newly-built single-family homes rose four points in July to a reading of 53 on the National Association of Home Builders/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index.

Industrial Production Rises in June   Full Article
Washington, DC, July 16, 2014 -- U.S. industrial production edged higher in June, according to the Federal Reserve on Wednesday.

Mortgage Applications Fall Last Week   Full Article
Washington, DC, July 16, 2014 -- Mortgage application volume fell 3.6% the week of July 11 from the previous week, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association.

J+J Flooring Group Offers Customized Rugs   Full Article
Dalton, GA, July 16, 2014 -- J+J Flooring Group has rolled out a new commercial customized area rug program called Invision Rugs that complements the broadloom and modular products offered by J+J brand Invision.

Shaw Releases Sixth Sustainability Report   Full Article
Dalton, GA, July 16, 2014 – Shaw Industries said it has released its sixth annual sustainability report.

New York Area Manufacturing Surges in July   Full Article
New York, NY, July 15, 2014 -- A New York-area manufacturing index rose to its highest level in more than four years this month.

Retail Sales Rise in June   Full Article
Washington, DC, July 15, 2014 -- Retail sales rose in June despite slower auto sales, according to the Commerce Department.

FIANA, CFI Planning Joint Event in September   Full Article
Vancouver, WA, July 15, 2014 -- The Floor Installation Association of North America and the Certified Floorcovering Installers are planning a joint convention in New Orleans Sept. 4-6.

Beaulieu International Group To Build Plant in Georgia   Full Article
Cartersville, GA, July 15, 2014 -- Beaulieu International Group said it will invest $200 million to build a campus-style manufacturing facility in Cartersville.

Volkswagen Chooses Chattanooga for New SUV   Full Article
Chattanooga, TN, July 14, 2014 -- Volkswagen said it will invest $600 million to build a new seven-passenger SUV at its factory in Chattanooga.

Median Age, Credit Scores For High-End Borrowers Fall   Full Article
New York, NY, July 14, 2014 -- The median age of borrowers seeking high balance mortgages has declined steadily over the last three years, according to private lender LoanDepot.

Meritage Homes To Acquire Atlanta Builder Legendary   Full Article
Scottsdale, AZ, July 14, 2014 -- Meritage Homes said it will acquire the Atlanta-based homebuilder Legendary Communities for approximately $130 million.