Survey 2012: What the Retailers Think - July 2012

By Darius Helm

 

While there’s no question that the residential flooring market is still sluggish, today’s dealers are more dynamic and engaged than ever. They seem to understand their businesses better—they know their suppliers, customers and competitors, and they see beyond the day to day to the bigger picture. Most of the respondents to our survey are the owners of retail operations, and this year they had plenty to say. However, for every criticism and negative comment, there was a suggestion, an insight or a constructive idea.

Next month is the sixth anniversary of the turning of the residential housing market, which has led to the most protracted residential flooring slowdown in modern history. One of the elements that has made this slowdown worse has been the inexorable rise in prices. Fifty years ago, this sort of economic performance would have rippled all the way up the chain, knocking down prices along the way, but now we’re in a global economy, and demand in emerging markets like China, India, Russia and Brazil is pushing up prices of everything from crude oil to floorcoverings.

In the U.S., independent flooring retailers have been beset on all sides, with reduced customers on one end, price increases on the other, and big box competition squeezing in from the left and right. And over the last six years, thousands of smaller dealers have shut their doors or sold their operations. 

The ones still standing haven’t survived just because of luck and location. They’ve been proactive, fighting for every customer—finding new ways to increase traffic to their stores, using all media to increase their visibility, broadening their offering, focusing on service, installation and even maintenance.

However, some flooring retailers are still “old school” both in terms of how they promote themselves and how they do the job of selling and installing flooring. For instance, in some regions of the country, a good 20% of retailers don’t have websites—and there’s no way that strategy is boosting their business.

One retailer commented, “Independent dealers need to embrace technology. Every dealer should throw out the ruler and paper and learn to use automated measure and estimating software—and use it during the sales process.”

WHO THEY ARE
This year’s surveyed dealers represent a very similar geographic spread to last year’s respondents. The biggest group is the Midwest, making up 35% of responses, and the smallest group is the East, at 17%—those are both the same as last year. The South accounts for another 27%, compared to 25% last year, and the balance, 21%, is from the West, which made up 23% of responses last year.

We asked retailers about the annual sales of their operations, and their responses featured some changes. Over the last few years, an increasing percentage of respondents have reported smaller sales, and that may be changing. This year, only 19% reported annual sales of less than $600,000, compared to 26% last year, 21% in 2010 and 9% in 2009. The bulk of the surveyed retailers, 70%, have annual sales of $2 million or less, and this follows the same curve—it was 75% in 2011, 71% in 2010 and 58% in 2009. So one possibility is that last year was the low point for annual sales and the industry may well be turning a corner, and the other possibility is that more of the small players have gone out of business or been consolidated.

This year, 12% reported sales over $5 million, compared to 10% last year and 14% in 2010 and 2009.
About 38% of the surveyed retailers pay their salespeople straight salaries and 22% pay straight commissions. The other 40% pay salary plus commission. That’s close to previous years—43% straight salaries last year, 45% in 2010 and 42% in 2009. However, there are some big regional differences. At one end of the spectrum are retailers from the East, with 51% paying straight salaries and only 8% straight commission, compared to retailers from the West, where 32% are straight salary and 31% straight commission.

About 18% of this year’s dealers have installers on staff, while 82% use independent contractors. In recent years, retailers in the Midwest and the South have leaned more heavily toward contractors than retailers in the East and West, and this year’s results reflects the same disparity, with 86% of retailers in the Midwest and the exact same percentage in the South using independent contractors, compared with only 76% in the East and, again, the same percentage in the West.

This year, 45% of surveyed dealers report being part of a retail group. That’s up slightly from last year but not to a significant degree. Regionally, 38% from the South and West are in retail groups, compared to 51% in the East and 52% in the Midwest.

Of the dealers that are members of groups, 90% report that they are very or somewhat satisfied, which is up from last year. Of those not affiliated, only 3% are considering joining a group.

For the complete Retailer Survey results, see the July 2012 issue of Floor Focus Magazine. 

Copyright 2012 Floor Focus



Other Archived Articles

CRI Posts Model Specification for Commercial Carpet   Full Article
Dalton, GA, July 9, 2014 -- The Carpet and Rug Institute said its Model Specification for Commercial Carpet is now available online at Carpet-Rug.org.

Bamboo Hardwoods Names Flooring Sales Director   Full Article
Seattle, WA, July 9, 2014 -- Bamboo Hardwoods has named Bruce Boulden as the company’s national flooring sales director.

Mortgage Application Volume Increases Last Week   Full Article
Washington, DC, July 9, 2014 -- Mortgage application volume rose last week, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association.

Ardex Academy Sets Training Dates   Full Article
Aliquippa, PA, July 9, 2014 -- Ardex Academy offers free classroom and hands-on product installation training at eight locations throughout North America. Participants learn substrate preparation and the newest installation techniques.

Judge Ends Laminate Copyright Dispute between Home Legend and Mannington   Full Article
Rome, GA July 3, 2014 -- A U.S. District Court in Rome, Georgia ruled in favor of Home Legend in a legal dispute over similar looking laminate floorcovering. The judge ruled nature can't be copyrighted.

Job Openings at Highest Level Since 2007   Full Article
Washington, DC, July 8, 2014 -- Job openings in the U.S. rose in April to the highest level since September 2007, according to the Labor Department.

CARE Seeking Proposals for PET Market Project   Full Article
Dalton, GA, July 8, 2014 -- Carpet America Recovery Effort is seeking proposals for a 12-18 month project to demonstrate value-added uses for polyethylene terephthalate (PET) derived from post-consumer PET carpets.

Quick-Step Hosts Event for Shelter Charity   Full Article
Dallas, TX, July 8, 2014 -- Laminate maker Quick-Step recently co-hosted an event to benefit the local charity Dwell With Dignity.

Prince of Wales Hosts Wool Campaign Event   Full Article
London, England, July 8, 2014 -- To commemorate the fifth anniversary of the Campaign for Wool, the campaign's Patron His Royal Highness The Prince of Wales hosted a major celebration of wool at Clarence House.

Curacao Firm Develops New Locking System   Full Article
Willemstad, Curacao, July 7, 2014 -- Innovations4Flooring, a technology company formed last year to supply flooring installation products, said it has developed a unique locking system for flooring.

UK Carpet Recycling Presents Awards   Full Article
Birmingham, England, July 7, 2014 -- Inspiration for manufacturers to design new carpet products for recycling or reuse at end of life was a key theme at Carpet Recycling UK’s sixth Annual Conference.

Estillon Wins Export Award in Netherlands   Full Article
Uden, The Netherlands, July 7, 2014 -- Estillon, a provider of subfloors, carpet underlays and accessories, took third prize for the Fenedex Frank Hauwert Trophy.

Mortgage Rates Lowest Since Last October   Full Article
Washington, DC, July 7, 2014 -- Mortgage rates hit 4.12% for a 30-year fixed rate last week, according to Freddie Mac.

Services Sector Growth Slows Slightly in June   Full Article
Tempe, AZ, July 3, 2014 -- Growth in the services sector of the economy slowed slightly in June, according to the Institute for Supply Management services index.

Planned Job Cuts Tumble in June   Full Article
Chicago, IL, July 3, 2014 -- Planned job cuts announced by U.S. companies in June fell to 31,434, the lowest level of the year and down 20% from a year ago, according to outplacement firm Challenger, Gray & Christmas.

Economy Adds 288,000 Jobs in June   Full Article
Washington, DC, July 3, 2014 -- Employers added 288,000 jobs in June, the Labor Department said Thursday.

Cersaie Show Set for Sept. 22-26 in Bologna   Full Article
Bologna, Italy, July 3, 2014 -- Cersaie—the world’s largest exhibition of ceramic tile and bathroom furnishings—will take place at the Bologna Exhibition Center in Bologna, Italy from Sept. 22-26.

NAFCD Issues Employee Compensation Report   Full Article
Chicago, IL, July 3, 2014 -- The North American Association of Floor Covering Distributors has released the 2014 NAFCD Employee Compensation Report.

E.J. Welch Promotes Two to Vice President   Full Article
St. Louis, MO, July 2, 2014 -- E.J. Welch Co. has promoted two employees to full time management positions.

Factory Orders Fall in May   Full Article
Washington, DC, July 2, 2014 -- Factory orders fell 0.5% in May, largely because of fewer orders for military goods, the Commerce Department said.