Compensation Strategies: Successful Selling

By Sam Allman

 

Leaders and managers are responsible for creating an environment in their organizations that is conducive to employee productivity. While it is debatable whether you can actually motivate others, you certainly can demotivate them by the environment in which they work. My message to leaders or managers is that if employees are not more productive because of your presence, then you are a cost to the system and are not needed. 

One of the outcomes expected of leaders or managers is productivity. Profitable companies are always looking for ways to cut costs, especially costs that bring no value to the organization. The measure of a leader or manager is results. Productivity is one of those results. It’s a scary thought that you, as the owner, may really be just an expense to your company.

Typical managers, when productivity is not where it needs to be, will point fingers and blame their people. You hear, “You just can’t find people who want to work anymore” or “If I could only find people who care like me.” Sounds like what is really needed is a boss-ectomy or an owner-ectomy. Great leaders and managers understand that when productivity is not up to par, it is not an employee problem. It is a leadership problem. When leaders claim the problem, they can take action to create the solution. Effective leaders and managers use leadership tactics to create an environment conducive to peak performance. Why do some CEOs command multi-million dollar salaries? They produce results—not just results, but optimal or extraordinary results. Effective leaders know how to influence the workers and the environment in which they work to enhance productivity. The most basic of tools or tactics that he can use to accomplish this is compensation. 

When was the last time you studied your compensation system? Is it helping to produce the results you desire? Are you sure? Are your people more productive because of it? If you haven’t paid attention to it lately, you may want to. Compensation is the basic factor that affects productivity and profitability. I might add here that I do not believe there is one best compensation system. Every system has its strengths and weaknesses. In addition, I will hopefully prove to you that any system you choose has to be supported by other fundamentally sound leadership tactics that reinforce the expectations desired.

COMPENSATION STRATEGIES
Compensation is one of the first areas we investigate as we help to improve the profitability and performance of our clients. One of the main reasons a company approaches business failure is that the wages of the employees, as a percentage of sales, begin to increase. We look at the wages of each person in the organization and compare it with the results they produce. We believe that each person in an organization should produce results commensurate with what they are paid. Our rule of thumb, at least for salespeople, is that they should produce three to five times their salary in gross profit. The actual number may vary depending on whether the person functions in inside or outside sales and how much help is needed for them to acquire customers. 

When results and wages are not congruent with expectations, we have to ask, “What is being rewarded?” According to Michael LeBoeuf, a professor of management at the University of New Orleans, the greatest management principle in the world is “things that get rewarded get done.” In other words, we get what we reward. As a parent, I found that if I gave in to my children every time they whined or made a fuss, I rewarded and reinforced the very behavior I was trying to squash. It wasn’t until my wife and I said “enough is enough” that our children’s behavior changed because we discontinued encouraging behavior we didn’t want.

That’s why many of the sales managers and owners with which I have worked say that the only way to pay a salesperson is on straight commission. Sometimes I agree, but not always. Everyone is different and is motivated by different reasons. Just because you are motivated by money doesn’t mean everyone is. I have personally seen salespeople who quit the last three months of the year because they had earned what they needed. Remember, when a need is satisfied, it no longer motivates.

If you incentivize salespeople, you have to be careful what you reward and be clear with what you want. I am intimately aware of a company that pays its salespeople on sales, and so that is what they get. Since the company does not allow lowering margins without management approval, margins are not affected much. However, it has created a dog-eat-dog environment with salespeople fighting over customers and refusing to help customers that are not theirs. Sales are being rewarded at the expense of customer satisfaction. I am reminded of a visitor in a mental health institution who became alarmed when he found that there were only three guards watching over 100 dangerous inmates and asked, “Don’t you feel these people will overpower the three of you and escape?” The reply was, “No, lunatics never unite.” Do incentives create lunacy?

You have to decide what you want: customer satisfaction or sales; teamwork or sales; margins or sales? You may reward one at the expense of others. I know one company that changed its compensation system from a percentage of sales to a percentage of profit, and within a few months its margins went from 35% to 43%. Decide what you want, then create a system that delivers it. Commission-based compensation systems work for people who are driven for monetary rewards. What about those who are more worried about security and a consistent income? Maybe a salary system will work better for them.

Some struggle using salary systems because of what is rewarded. What do you reward salespeople when you only pay them a salary? You reward them for just showing up, because all you are doing is paying them for putting in time. So that’s what you get unless your system is supported by effective leadership tactics. A salary can be effective if it is accompanied by clear expectations (quotas for specific desired results), performance metrics and a system of accountability. A salary plus a small commission for sales, margins or a share in company profits will improve the effectiveness of a salary system. You may have different systems functioning in your business at the same time, because you may want to maximize the performance of each of your people. Employees are all different, and they all have different needs.

MOTIVATING FORCES
Incentives, commissions and recognition are examples of extrinsic rewards or, as they are also called, carrots. Again, the problem with carrots is they only motivate you if you want them. In his book, Drive, Daniel Pink reminds us of decades-old research on human motivation that proves that humans are at least as strongly motivated by intrinsic satisfactions that come from learning, playing and being curious as they are by carrots or even by the fear of the stick (punishments). Salary systems work because some workers need a certain baseline of comfort and security, so he claims that additional external rewards actually serve as de-motivators.

In fact, as Pink compellingly points out, humans are naturally autonomous and self-directed toward contributing and engaging in life. What’s interesting is that he reminds us that most leaders are completely oblivious to this scientifically accepted fact. Reflecting on his treatise, I consider those who like to work but play harder at things that are important to them. I refer to my son Jim. He is a triathlete. He works hard at staying in shape so he can participate in triathlons. When he works out, he swims, bikes and runs. Amazing, he doesn’t get paid for it. Why couldn’t I get him to work like that when he was a kid? I even offered to pay. Every one of us has passions that tax us and require us to exert ourselves. We don’t get paid for doing them, and most of the time we have to pay to do them. Maybe we should make work a game and more of our people will more deeply engage. We can buy our employees hands, but we can’t buy their hearts.

Pink reminds us that we all want to be paid fairly for our efforts But we also want to do good work, challenge ourselves, get better at something that matters and make a contribution. He says money is a motivator, but it is also a form of feedback. Monetary rewards are important, says Pink, because “the workplace is one of the most feedback-deprived environments around.” Feedback is the “breakfast of champions.”

He shared a story about a CEO who made the decision to eliminate commissions. He raised base salaries and increased end-of-the-year profit sharing. Personally, I like profit sharing because it gives everyone a stake in results produced by the whole organization. The CEO found that the sales reps collaborated more because they were no longer pitted against each other. Total sales went up and so did customer satisfaction, making it a win/win for all stakeholders.

Pink proposes a motivational system that is based on three pillars: autonomy: the urge to direct and be in control of our own lives; mastery: the desire to get better and better at something that matters; and purpose: yearning to do what we do in the service of something larger than ourselves—it is our ultimate need, the need to contribute. It’s the motivation that causes people to work hard and donate their time and efforts to causes they believe are worthy. 

Whatever commission system you choose to implement, you have to monitor it and be aware of the results it is providing. Remember the importance of fairness. If people aren’t getting paid fairly relative to other people in your organization doing comparable work, then that’s a motivation destroyer. If your employees feel that they are not being paid fairly, they will justify slacking or, even worse, stealing.

Finally, critical to your system is the support that you give it using other leadership tactics. Even Pink asserted that it is important not to eliminate that support in any type of commission system. Those tactics include: communicating clear performance expectations; monitoring the important performance metrics; and an accountability system that requires your employee to report back on the progress you expect. You need to inspect what you expect! Consider your compensation system; is it helping to increase productivity? Do you need to support the system more effectively or do you need to change it? You decide.

Copyright 2013 Floor Focus

 



Other Archived Articles

Job Openings Edge Down in September   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 13, 2014 -- There were 4.7 million job openings on the last business day of September, according to the Labor Department.

NWFA Approves Vermeister Finish Products   Full Article
St. Louis, MO, Nov. 13, 2014 -- The National Wood Flooring Association said that Vermeister S.p.A. has been approved for the NWFA Accepted Product Seal and NWFA Accepted Eco Product Seal designations.

Dixie Discontinuing Carousel Custom Line   Full Article
Chattanooga, TN, Nov. 13, 2014 -- The Dixie Group said it will discontinue its Carousel custom manufacturing line.

CRI Outlines 2015 Initiatives at Annual Meeting   Full Article
Dalton, GA, Nov. 13, 2014 -- The Carpet and Rug Institute (CRI) held its annual meeting in Dalton, Ga. yesterday.

Initial Jobless Claims Remain Below 300K   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 13, 2014 -- Initial jobless claims increased by 12,000 to 290,000 in the week ended Nov. 8, according to the Labor Department.

Resilient Institute Adds Seven New Members   Full Article
LaGrange, GA, Nov. 13, 2014 -- The Resilient Floor Covering Institute has expanded membership, adding four manufacturers and three suppliers to its roster.

Distributor Fishman Rolls Out Private Label Flooring   Full Article
Baltimore, MD, Nov. 13, 2014 -- Distributor Fishman Flooring Solutions said it is entering the private label flooring business.

Foreclosure Filings Spike in September   Full Article
Irvine, CA, Nov. 13, 2014 -- Foreclosure filings were reported on 123,109 properties in October, according to tracking firm RealtyTrac.

Wholesale Inventories Rise in September   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 12, 2014 -- U.S. wholesale inventories rose 0.3% in September after a 0.6% gain in August, according to the Commerce Department.

Beazer Homes Returns To Profit for Year   Full Article
Atlanta, GA, Nov. 12, 2014 -- Beazer Homes reported fiscal fourth-quarter net income of $59.8 million or $1.88 per share, compared to $11.9 million a year ago.

Mortgage Applications Fall Last Week   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 12, 2014 -- Applications for U.S. home mortgages fell last week as interest rates rose, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association.

NAFCD Names Award Winners   Full Article
Chicago, IL, Nov. 12, 2014 -- The North American Association of Floor Covering Distributors has named the winners of its Leadership in Action and Lifetime Achievement awards.

First TISE East Draws International Attendees   Full Article
Dallas, TX, Nov. 12, 2014 -- Hanley Wood Exhibitions said that its first-ever International Surface Event East featured 185 exhibiting companies covering over 50,000 square feet of booths and displays.

NAFCD Urges Members To Support Habitat Stores   Full Article
Chicago, IL, Nov. 11, 2014 -- The North American Association of Floor Covering Distributors Association is urging its members to support Habitat for Humanity's ReStores by donating materials and products.

Former Mannington VP Hollinger Dies   Full Article
Kennett Square, PA, Nov. 11, 2014 -- Mark A. Hollinger, age 58, a long-time Mannington Mills employee, died Nov. 5 after a year long battle with glioblastoma multiforme.

Desso Using Water Company Waste in Carpet Tile   Full Article
Waalwijk, The Netherlands, Nov. 11, 2014 -- Carpet company Desso said it is using chalk from local water companies to make its products.

Investment Adviser Reduces Stake in Armstrong   Full Article
Boston, MA, Nov. 11, 2014 -- Wellington Management Company of Boston has reduced its stake in Armstrong World Industries to less than 5% of the firm.

Mr. David's Founders Named Persons of Year   Full Article
Chicago, IL, Nov. 11, 2014 -- David and Leonard Zmijewski, the founders of Mr. David's Flooring International, have been named Persons of the Year by the Chicago Floor Covering Association.

Dover Rug & Home Wins Philanthropy Award   Full Article
Natick, MA, Nov. 10, 2014 -- Dover Rug & Home said it is the recipient of the 2014 Community Excellence Award, given by the Family Business Association of Massachusetts.

More Home Refinancers Taking Cash at Closing   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 10, 2014 -- Borrowers cashed out an estimated $8 billion in home equity through refinancing of conventional mortgages in the third quarter, according to Freddie Mac’s quarterly refinancing report.