Commoditization: Channel Wars

By Jim Dion

 

In today’s hypercompetitive marketplace, more products are becoming commoditized by both online and brick-and-mortar retailers. For an increasing number of products, the retail price has been falling faster than productivity gains would ordinarily warrant, and the result has been ever-declining margins for most retailers.

This “race to the bottom” has been fueled by a weak economy, which for the past five years has made it very difficult for both the consumer and retailer to thrive, as well as by Smartphone technology, which gives the consumer the ability to check prices in the store as they shop. Consumers no longer have to drive from one retailer to another to comparison shop, they can do it right from a showroom. This ease of use means that customers are comparison-shopping even for small purchases. 

THE LOSS LEADER TACTIC 
To satiate the consumer’s price obsession, many retailers, both online and omni-channel brick-and-mortar retailers, have been using the loss leader tactic to an extreme, which means pricing an item at a loss, sometimes below cost, to either drive traffic to the store or website or to take a leadership position in that category. It can be predatory in nature and used to hamper or eliminate competition. 

For flooring retailers, this means taking one or two categories and pricing them very aggressively to gain traffic, then hoping that the customer will buy some of the better margin items in their assortments. Ads for $0.49 per square foot laminate and $1.69 per square foot engineered hardwood are examples of this type of marketing. Once the customer is in the store, the retailer hopes to upsell them on to a higher priced product or add in higher-margin extras to make up for the loss. 

This strategy isn’t used only in flooring. The most notable example of this sort of category decimation is flat panel TVs. The average retail profit margin on flat panel TVs today is less than 14%. It is simply impossible for most retail stores to cover basic overheads with this margin, much less make a profit, so retailers who are faced with this reality find other categories—such as audio, furniture and bedding—that will provide a better margin and use the higher margin categories to offset the lower margin category. This can work for retailers who can afford to carry other categories at a higher profit margin in their store, but it can also lead to scramble merchandising, confusing the customer with categories that they did not expect to find in the store and obscure the true nature of a business. Yes, some like Nebraska Furniture Mart can get away with selling carpeting and appliances, but they are truly unique.

FIGHTING THE RACE TO THE BOTTOM
Many retailers are awakening to the reality that they cannot afford to join these races to the bottom and are fighting back on two fronts that go beyond just adding more profitable categories to offset the unprofitable. 

Many of the larger retailers and buying groups have created their own private label products, which removes them from the comparison price trap. This is a strategy well-tested outside the world of flooring. Retailers like The Gap, Victoria’s Secret and Brooks Brothers never ventured into selling other brands and, instead, made their store brand highly desirable. Others, like Ace Hardware, carry name brands but also have their own private label to compete with the name brands. 

When a retailer has their own brand, they control the price at which a product is sold. No one can undersell them, and any online search that the customer conducts comes back with their price. 

Some retailers that can’t afford to private label, like many mom-and-pop stores, can utilize a bundling strategy to help them compete, offering the consumer a price that includes product and services—such as measuring, design, removal, delivery, installation—so that they cannot comparison shop the product price.

Retailers who choose to carry brand name products know that customers will “showroom” them, using their Smartphones to compare their prices to other retailers’ or doing a side-by-side search of a retailer’s brick-and-mortar versus online pricing. Many customers are gravitating towards suppliers and brands that enforce a minimum advertised price (MAP) or, even better, have a unilateral price structure in place, setting a minimum selling price for an item, advertised or not. Often, the UP is the same as the manufacturers suggested retail price (MSRP). 

More suppliers today are putting UP or MAP policies in place, recognizing that, if they do not, the dealers who do support their brand by offering great displays, knowledgeable staffs and value-add services will not survive the price wars, and then the supplier will be left with only large volume discount channels that do not enhance their brand image and will eventually destroy it. 

Ultimately, if you do not build your own brand, you have to rely on quality suppliers that will partner with you and respect what you do for their brand. And suppliers need to realize that opening their own stores or selling on their websites will eventually destroy their retail partners and turn the supplier into a completely vertical operator, an almost impossible mode of operation today. Retailers add value to suppliers, and the relationship between them needs to be symbiotic if everyone—supplier, retailer and consumer—is to win.

Copyright 2013 Floor Focus



Other Archived Articles

Retail Sales Flat in July   Full Article
Retail Sales were flat in July as car demand slowed and consumers remained cautious in their spending. This is the weakest performance in six months.

Mortgage Application Volume Down Last Week   Full Article
New York, NY, Aug. 13, 2014 -- Mortgage application volume fell last week as both purchase and refinancing applications declined, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association.

Valinge Awarded Another U.S. Patent   Full Article
Viken, Sweden, Aug. 13, 2014 -- Valinge said it has been awarded a U.S. patents regarding mechanical locking of LVT/resilient floorboards.

Another Investment Firm Discloses Armstrong Position   Full Article
New York, NY, Aug. 13, 2014 -- Another investment firm has disclosed a large position in the shares of Armstrong World Industries.

Home Price Increases Continue To Moderate   Full Article
Washington, DC, Aug. 12, 2014 -- Home-price growth continued to moderate in many metropolitan areas in the second quarter, according to the National Association of Realtors.

Domotex Turkey 2015 Set for May   Full Article
Hannover, Germany, Aug. 12, 2014 -- The dates for Domotex Turkey 2015 are May 25-28 at the Turkish carpet trading capital, Gaziantep.

Job Openings Edge Higher in June   Full Article
Washington, DC, Aug. 12, 2014 -- Job openings increased to 4.67 million in June, according to the latest Job Openings and Labor Turnover Summary from the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Ceramic Tile Standards Subject of Gathering in SC   Full Article
Clemson, SC, Aug. 12, 2014 -- International trade and standards for ceramic tile were the focus of discussions as delegates from 15 countries met in Clemson to develop new standards.

Propex Marks 50th Anniversary of Polybac   Full Article
Hazlehurst, GA, Aug. 11, 2014 -- Propex recently celebrated a significant milestone for the carpet industry at its Hazlehurst manufacturing facility.

Realtors Applaud FICO Calculation Changes   Full Article
Washington, DC, Aug. 11, 2014 -- The National Association of Realtors said it supports the decision of Fair Issac to make some changes related to how it calculates FICO credit scores.

CRI's Seal of Approval Certifies Several Products   Full Article
Dalton, GA, Aug. 11, 2014 -- The Carpet and Rug Institute's Seal of Approval testing and certification program for carpet cleaning supplies and equipment has certified several products.

Wholesale Inventories Rise in June   Full Article
Washington, DC, Aug. 8, 2014 -- Wholesale inventories rose 0.3% in June, the same as the previous month, according to the Commerce Department.

Retail Credit May Come Easier for Many Borrowers   Full Article
New York, NY, Aug. 8, 2014 -- Obtaining retail credit could come easier for millions of Americans following a change in how the most widely used credit score is calculated

Carpet One Members Hear Two Famous Speakers   Full Article
Grapevine, TX, Aug. 8, 2014 -- Carpet One Floor & Home members gathered this week to network with their fellow store members and receive updates on new products and programs.

Mats Inc. Flooring a Finalist in USGBC Program   Full Article
Stoughton, MA, Aug. 8, 2014 -- Purline flooring by Mats Inc. has been named a finalist in the U.S. Green Building Council’s Best of Building Awards 2014 in two categories.

More Markets Returning to Normal in Housing   Full Article
Washington, DC, Aug. 7, 2014 -- Markets in 56 of the approximately 350 metro areas nationwide returned to or exceeded their last normal levels of economic and housing activity in the second quarter.

Builder Confidence Grows in Senior Housing   Full Article
Washington, DC, Aug. 7, 2014 -- Builder confidence in the single-family senior housing market for the second quarter is up year over year, according to the National Association of Home Builders.

Initial Jobless Claims Fall Last Week   Full Article
Washington, DC, Aug. 7, 2014 -- Initial claims for unemployment benefits fell by 14,000 to 289,000 in the week ending Aug. 2, according to the Labor Department.

Investment Firm Takes Significant Stake in Armstrong   Full Article
New York, NY, Aug. 7, 2014 -- San Francisco investment firm ValueAct Capital now owns 16.8% of Armstrong World Industries' common stock.

Surya Breaks Ground on Cartersville Headquarters   Full Article
Cartersville, GA, Aug. 7, 2014 -- Rug company Surya held a groundbreaking ceremony for its $33.5 million, 1-million-square-foot warehouse and headquarters facility in Cartersville.