Acceptable Concrete Moisture - July 2013

Acceptable Concrete Moisture From July 2013

In April, Concrete Construction magazine published the article “Why Three Pounds?” that questions why the flooring industry ever abided by what it calls a “one size fits all” standard for evaluating concrete slab moisture. According to the article, “The literature from many flooring installers and manufacturers states that installation of glued-on flooring cannot begin, and warranties on flooring materials will not be honored, if MVER [moisture vapor emission rates] results are greater than 3.0 pounds/1000 square feet/24 hours (abbreviated in this article as simply 3 pounds); some manufacturers today have increased that to 5 pounds. It is not clear if this value refers to the results of any single test, of all tests, or the average of all tests required by ASTM F 1869 to be performed on the slab simultaneously.” So is the three-pound requirement as arbitrary as the authors of the article suggest?

The concrete moisture issue is one that causes continual frustration to nearly every segment of the flooring industry: manufacturers, contractors, installers and specifiers. This problem has become more prevalent in recent years due to the accelerated timelines for construction and the types of adhesives used today.

A three-pound moisture vapor emission rate (MVER) was for years recognized as the limit of moisture that could be safely tolerated by flooring materials and adhesives. An MVER above three pounds was believed to put many types of flooring materials and installations at risk.

The issue the authors raise isn’t only why an MVER limit was originally set to three pounds, but also how one can reliably determine that the moisture vapor emission rate is actually at or below three pounds—as well as whether reaching a three pound limit is really necessary. The authors argue that there is no direct correlation between a three-pound emission rate and the occurrence of flooring failures.

Since the calcium chloride method of measuring the MVER has been around for many years, much has been learned about what the test method does and does not indicate. Some of the limitations with the test hinge on the fact that the moisture content of a slab is mutable and that MVER results are in great part affected by the ambient conditions that the slab has been exposed to before and during the test period. Even if a concrete slab is considered acceptably dry, this does not mean that the moisture level within the concrete will remain at a static level if the underside of the slab is not adequately protected from moisture below. In addition it has been shown that the MVER test only reflects the amount of moisture present in the top 1/2” to 3/4” of the concrete slab.

According to concrete floor specialist Peter Craig, the most important element in the design and construction of a concrete subfloor where a moisture-sensitive finish is to be applied is an effective, low-permeance vapor barrier placed directly beneath the slab. If the barrier below the slab is absent, the results of any type of moisture test cannot be relied upon, as the moisture content of the slab will increase over time once the slab is covered.

Keep in mind that the relative humidity in the ground below the slab will be close to 100%, regardless of the depth of the water table, and that the humidity at the top of a concrete slab cannot be lower than the humidity in the air above it. In a humid environment, like the Southeast, the top portion of a concrete slab can only dry to the level of the air, so an MVER test will measure a higher level than, for instance, a slab in a dry desert environment. And, of course, this level will change with the air, so a slab will have a higher moisture content reading on a more humid day, when the surface of the slab absorbs more moisture. An MVER test only reveals what is happening in the very top portion of the slab, which is impacted by the air; it does not indicate the humidity at the slab’s core or the transmission of moisture through the slab.

According to Craig, with an effective barrier in place, the best means of measuring a slab’s moisture condition is to perform both MVER and in-situ RH testing (ASTM F2170-11). Measuring the RH level of a properly protected slab-on-ground at 40% of the slab’s thickness is a predictor of what the uniform RH level will be in the slab after it is covered. 

As adhesives are developed that can withstand greater exposure to moisture and elevated pH conditions, tolerable moisture levels will likely rise, and with them, warranties will change. In the meantime, experts agree that multiple tests in multiple areas is the best way to determine the moisture condition of a slab, a crucial determination to ensure the successful installation of a floorcovering.

 

Copyright 2013 Floor Focus 



Other Archived Articles

Flooring Firm Fire Ruled Spontaneous Combustion   Full Article
Chesterfield County, VA, Aug. 5, 2014 -- A July fire at Better Floors has been ruled a "spontaneous combustion" incident by investigators.

Factory Orders Spike in June   Full Article
Washington, DC, Aug. 5, 2014 -- Factory orders surged in June by 1.1%, the Commerce Department said.

Services Sector Growth Fastest in Nine Years   Full Article
Tempe AZ, Aug. 5, 2014 -- The services sector of the economy grew in July at the fastest pace in nine years, according to the Institute for Supply Management.

Kansas City Interiors Icon Bernie Madden Dies   Full Article
Leawood, KS, Aug. 5, 2014 -- William Bernard "Bernie" Madden, owner of Madden McFarland Interiors died Aug. 1.

Flooring America's Rebranded Meeting Underway   Full Article
Dallas, TX, Aug. 5, 2014 -- Flooring America/Flooring Canada, a division of CCA Global Partners, has kicked-off conneXtion, its newly branded bi-annual meeting that connects its more than 500 independent floor covering retailers.

Mullican Flooring in Two 'Flipping Boston' Episodes   Full Article
Johnson City, TN, Aug. 5, 2014 -- Mullican Flooring has provided hardwood flooring for two additional episodes of “Flipping Boston,” a television series on the A&E channel.

Latricrete Acquires Resinous Flooring Firm Spartacote   Full Article
Bethany, CT, Aug. 5, 2014 -- Laticrete International said it has acquired HP Spartacote.

J+J Symposium Focuses on Senior Design Trends   Full Article
Dalton, GA, Aug. 4, 2014 -- J+J Flooring Group recently hosted the first in a series of senior living design symposiums in which experts discussed the driving trends.

Florida Tile Opens Showroom in Boise   Full Article
Boise, ID, Aug. 4, 2014 -- Florida Tile has opened its second tile and stone showroom in four months, this one in Boise on July 15.

GBCI, Bureau Veritas Form Partnership   Full Article
Washington, DC, Aug. 4, 2014 -- The Green Building Certification Institute and Bureau Veritas SA have announced a strategic business partnership.

Berkshire Hathaway Reports Decline in Shaw's Earnings   Full Article
Omaha, NE, Aug. 4, 2014 -- Shaw Industries recorded a pre-tax earnings decline for the second quarter due to lower margins, according to parent company Berkshire Hathaway's quarterly report.

Manufacturing Expands at Faster Pace   Full Article
Tempe, AZ, Aug. 1, 2014 -- U.S. manufacturing expanded at its fastest rate since April 2011, according to the Institute for Supply Management.

Personal Spending, Income Rise in June   Full Article
Washington, DC, Aug. 1, 2014 -- Consumer spending increased modestly in June, according to Commerce Department statistics.

Construction Spending Falls on Commercial Weakness   Full Article
Washington, DC, Aug. 1, 2014 -- Construction spending fell by 1.8% in June, mostly due to lower spending on commercial projects, according to the Commerce Department.

Consumer Sentiment Ticks Down in July   Full Article
Ann Arbor, MI, Aug. 1, 2014 -- The Thomson Reuters/University of Michigan final reading of consumer sentiment for July edged down to 81.8 from 82.5 in June.

Economy Adds 209K Jobs, Unemployment Edges Up   Full Article
Washington, DC, Aug. 1, 2014 -- The economy added 209,000 jobs in July, the Labor Department said.

Mohawk Reports Higher Earnings, Sales in Q2   Full Article
Calhoun, GA, July 31, 2014 -- Mohawk Industries reported second quarter net earnings of $153 million and earnings per share of $2.08 on net sales of $2.05 billion.

Planned Job Cuts Grow Due To Tech Layoffs   Full Article
Chicago, IL, July 31, 2014 -- Announced job cuts by U.S. employers in July totaled 46,887, according to outplacement firm Challenger, Gray & Christmas.

Chicago Area Manufacturing Expands at Slower Rate   Full Article
Chicago, IL, July 31, 2014 -- The Chicago Purchasing Managers Index fell sharply in July to its lowest level in more than a year.

Unemployment Claims Rise Last Week   Full Article
Washington, DC, July 31, 2014 -- Initial jobless claims jumped last week after falling to a 14-year low the week before.