Judge Ends Laminate Copyright Dispute between Home Legend and Mannington

Rome, GA July 3, 2014 -- A U.S. District Court in Rome, Georgia ruled in favor of Home Legend in a legal dispute that started on Sept. 28, 2012 when Mannington filed a “cease and desist” order alleging that Home Legend’s Distressed Maple laminate collection infringes on Mannington’s “Glazed Maple” copyright.

Home Legend's counter suit filed Oct. 8, 2012 sought to declare Mannington’s copyright invalid.

On April 9, 2013, the same court denied Mannington’s request for a preliminary injunction that would have forced Home Legend to remove its Maple Laminate floor collection from over 1,800 Home Depot stores.

In granting Home Legend summary judgment, which dismisses Mannington’s infringement claims, U.S. District Judge Harold L. Murphy found that not only was it not possible to copyright nature, Mannington had sought a copyright for a process and a useful article — two things for which there is no protection.

“The court concludes that the subject matter of the copyright — the 2D artwork — was not entitled to copyright protection,” Murphy’s order said.

Mannington argued that the artwork used in the laminate flooring was intended to look like rustic wood, which Murphy said lacked originality because the company “simply attempted to recreate the look of natural, rustic wood in another medium — artwork.”

Mannington argued that its design does not resemble actual wood grain. But Murphy, citing a California federal court decision in the 2013 case Proline Concrete Tools Inc. vs. Gord Dennis et al,  said that doesn't matter. He said the key point is that Mannington tried to reproduce something that occurs naturally and sought copyright protection for it.

When contacted by Floor Focus Magazine, Dan Natkin, director of Hardwood and Laminate Business for Mannington Mills, said,  “We are aware of the lower court decision regarding the copyright of Mannington’s laminate floor designs, and we’re considering our available legal options moving forward.”

 



Other Archived Articles

Oil Prices Continue Downward Slide   Full Article
New York, NY, Oct. 10, 2014 -- Oil prices extended their free fall Friday.

Economists See Stronger 2015 Economy   Full Article
New York, NY, Oct. 10, 2014 -- Stronger job growth, increasing consumer confidence, and falling oil prices should aid the economic expansion next year, the Wall Street Journal reported.

Tarkett Holding Year-End Sales Promotion   Full Article
Chagrin Falls, OH, Oct. 10, 2014 -- Tarkett said it is holding its biggest sales promotion ever through the end of the year.

Karndean Promotes Hanno to Sales Director   Full Article
Export, PA, Oct. 10, 2014 -- Karndean Designflooring has promoted Tim Hanno to director of retail sales, effective immediately.

Tight Lending Standards Still Hurting Home Builders   Full Article
Washington, DC, Oct. 9, 2014 -- Tight mortgage lending standards continue to affect sales for single-family builders, according to a survey released by the National Association of Home Builders.

Wholesale Inventories Increase in August   Full Article
Washington, DC, Oct. 9, 2014 -- U.S. wholesale inventories rose 0.7% in August, according to the Commerce Department.

Initial Jobless Claims Hold Steady Last Week   Full Article
Washington, DC, Oct. 9, 2014 -- Initial jobless claims held steady at 287,000 last week, according to the Labor Department.

Quick-Step Starts Promoting Q-Wood Flooring on the Internet   Full Article
Dallas, TX, Oct. 9, 2014 -- Quick-Step developed a new website specifically for its Q-Wood category of flooring.

Mortgage Application Volume Rises Last Week   Full Article
Washington, DC, Oct. 8, 2014 -- Mortgage application volume increased 3.8% last week from the previous week, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association.

Got You Floored on Fast 50 List in Piedmont Region   Full Article
Greensboro, NC, Oct. 8, 2014 -- -Got You Floored, Inc. was named by the Triad Business Journal to the Fast 50 for the Piedmont Triad Region in North Carolina.

Georgia Gov. Deal Visits Mohawk in Calhoun   Full Article
Calhoun, GA, Oct. 7, 2014 -- Earlier this week, Georgia Gov. Nathan Deal toured the Mohawk Flooring Center in Calhoun and spoke to employees about the importance of the flooring industry in the state of Georgia.

Interface Issues Third Quarter Earnings Warning   Full Article
New York, NY, Oct. 8, 2014 -- Shares of Interface fell 16.5% in after-hours trading Tuesday after the company announced lower-than-expected preliminary third-quarter results.

National Retail Federation Expects Holiday Sales Boost   Full Article
Washington, DC, Oct. 7, 2014 -- Retail spending during the holiday season is expected to be the highest in three years, according to a forecast by the National Retail Federation.

Job Openings Highest Since 2001   Full Article
Washington, DC, Oct. 7, 2014 -- Job openings increased to 4.84 million in August, up from 4.67 million in July, according to the latest Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey.

Builders Offering Incentives as Sales Soften   Full Article
New York, NY, Oct. 7, 2014 -- Home builders nationally have begun sweetening offers in light of slowing sales, according to a Bloomberg News story.

Domotex To Feature Installation Technology for First Time   Full Article
Hannover, Germany, Oct. 7, 2014 -- Domotex 2015 set for Jan. 17-20 will feature 1,300 exhibitors from more than 60 countries.

Fincibec Group Seeking Tile Award Entries   Full Article
Sassuolo, Italy, Oct. 6, 2014 -- The Quinquennial Tile Award, now in its fourth edition, seeking entries using the Fincibec Group's three brands, Century, Monocibec and Naxos, between Jan. 1, 2011 and Dec. 31, 2015.

Armstrong Raising Some Vinyl Prices   Full Article
Lancaster, PA, Oct. 6, 2014 -- Armstrong said it will raise prices in the U.S. and Canada on commercial vinyl composition tile and BioBased Tile by 4%, commercial wallbase by 4%, and select residential tile products.

Stifel Sees Stronger Hard Surface Sales, Weaker Carpet Sales   Full Article
New York, NY, Oct. 6, 2014 -- Analyst Stifel Nicolaus believes that third quarter flooring sales will show stronger sales of hard surface flooring and weaker sales of carpet.

NeoCon East Offers Education for Designers   Full Article
Baltimore, MD, Oct. 6, 2014 -- NeoCon East has announced its educational program for design professionals seeking continuing education.