Strategic Exchange - January 2012

By Kemp Harr

 

At Floor Focus, we’re junkies for good research and we’ve always believed that you’re only as smart as what the market tells you. Recently we were given a preview of market research data and were able to peer into the minds of 700 consumers who had either bought flooring in the last 12 months or were planning to buy flooring in the next 12 months. Interestingly enough, those planning to buy far outnumber the ones who have already bought, by a greater margin than at anytime in the last six years. 

Another important nugget is that the three most influential resources used to gather information during the selection/buying process were: 1. Recommendations from friends and family; 2. Product displays in stores; 3. Websites from major home centers. So, if you’re a retailer, making sure your clients are happy and that they love the flooring they’ve selected is critical, and making sure your store’s merchandising system is uncluttered and efficient is also important. 

When consumers are asked what the most important criteria are for selecting a floor, they rate quality, aesthetics and durability ahead of price, and as you scroll down the top 16 items on the list, “made in America” is number 14. And further down from that is sustainability and even below that is a salesperson’s recommendation. One more important comment on price before we leave that topic: not only is price not one of the top deciding factors in the selection process but it is less of a factor today than it was two years ago. And while the importance of price has gone down, durability and lasting beauty had gone up.

When asked what room they were selecting floors for, the top five rooms on the list (in order) were bathroom, living room, family room, kitchen and master bedroom.

One disturbing and yet understandable statistic dealt with where the consumer first started shopping; 66% start with the home center, 16% start with a specialty flooring story, and 11% start online. Granted, a higher percentage of shoppers who started shopping at the specialty flooring store actually ended up buying there (82%). But home centers do a surprisingly better job of closing their customers than one might think (75%).

When asked whether social media was a factor in the decision making process, only extreme social media users said it was a factor, and demographically they tend to be younger in age.

PRELIMINARY YEAR-END NUMBERS
Santo Torcivia’s December market report released year-end dollar consumption figures for the U.S. by flooring category. Carpet and rug is up 1.7%, hardwood is up 1.2%, ceramic tile is up 5%, resilient flooring is up 2%, and laminate is down 11.8%. 

These laminate numbers are somewhat surprising. The laminate category is being hurt from two directions. LVT visuals are just as realistic without the acoustical issues that are typical with laminates, and pricing for engineered hardwood is competitive enough for people to buy the real thing. 

Another item that caught my eye is the import numbers for tufted carpets and rugs, which are up 13% year to date on top of a 17% increase in 2010 over 2009. For 2011, India leads the growth with a 16% increase and that’s mostly rugs. However, imports out of China are up almost 14% and that’s more likely a mix of broadloom and rugs.

You can’t help but note that the top line revenue numbers for the home centers are outpacing the overall retail figures and the flooring store numbers. Year-to-date, the home centers have grown 4.9%, while overall retail is up 3.2% and flooring store sales are down 3.9%. What you can’t tell from those numbers is whether the flooring department within the home centers continues to track with the rest of the store. Our last good estimate was that the flooring department represented about 6% of the overall number. Conversations we’ve had with a few key flooring suppliers to the home centers tell us that business within the home centers continues to outpace what they are seeing in the overall market.

Santo points out that the U.S. dollar has bounced back, which makes exports more expensive and imports cheaper. 

Dollars spent on consumer advertising by flooring companies is up 6.8%, which would seem to indicate that they’re betting that demand will improve in 2012.

BLUE RIDGE CLOSES
It was sad to see Blue Ridge Carpet Mills close late last year. Blue Ridge, a commercial carpet mill based in Ellijay, Georgia, operated for 43 years, with peak sales in 2005 at over $50 million. 

The company had primary focus on the commercial office business, a secondary focus on retail floors and it was known for its patterned broadloom products. In 2002, Blue Ridge entered the modular carpet sector when it acquired Lowe’s Carpets.

Blue Ridge struggled throughout the recession and wasn’t able to hold on long enough for the market, and in particular the corporate office sector, to recover. The demise of the company was due, in part, to the fact that it wasn’t vertically integrated and had only one plant, so it couldn’t consolidate operations to cut costs. And, while the company’s management was talented, much of its equipment was dated. For several years, Blue Ridge was able to develop very distinctive products but wasn’t able to carve out a sustainable following that could carry it through the downturn. In the end, I’m not sure if it was the lack of A&D connection with the folksy brand image or just too many other mills with the same look and a better balance sheet. I do know that the company didn’t have the resources to either invest in its brand or to build out a competitive sustainability platform—both of which are necessary to compete in this market.

Blue Ridge opened its doors in 1968 as Davis Mills with a Small Business Administration loan to its founder, Ralph Davis. Through its history, it was owned by the Lowy Group (a floorcovering distributor/wholesaler based in St. Louis); a private equity firm in Houston, Texas; and River and Associates based in Chattanooga, Tennessee. Mike Gallman, former CEO, spent 21 years at Shaw Industries before taking the helm at Blue Ridge in 1998.

CHANGING OF THE GUARD
The recent announcement about the two new business unit leaders at Mohawk and Dal-Tile brings to light the abundant changes in key leadership positions within the manufacturing sector of this industry. One of the most interesting details is that all of these new leaders are flooring industry veterans. With Mohawk, Frank Peters is stepping down, and 46 year old Brian Carson, who spent 16 years at Armstrong, is taking over as president. At Dal-Tile, J.T. Turner Jr. is taking the helm as Harold Turk steps down. In, J.T.’s case, he’s been with Dal-Tile for 21 years.

At Mannington Mills, Tom Davis is retiring after 18 years and Russell Grizzle is taking over as president and CEO. In this case, it appears that chairman and owner Keith Campbell likes the Milliken leadership training system. Tom came over from Millken 18 years ago and Russell spent 31 years at Milliken prior to making this move.

We recently noted that James Lesslie, who started in the fiber business at Allied Signal 29 years ago, spent ten years at Queen/Shaw and most recently seven years at Beaulieu as COO, has now joined Bob Shaw at Engineered Floors as the assistant to the chairman.

Earlier this year, Paul Murfin, who spent four years at Beaulieu and six years at Armstrong, took the helm as president of IVC.

Brad Townsend recently took the vice president of sales role at J&J Industries after spending 27 years at Shaw. 

David Vita, who now holds the top spot at Beaulieu Commercial, spent 22 years at Shaw before making the switch.

And Lindsay Ann Waldrep recently took Crossville’s marketing vice president position after spending six years at Mohawk and four years before that at Harris Tarkett. 


Copyright 2012 Floor Focus 



Other Archived Articles

Job Openings Edge Down in September   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 13, 2014 -- There were 4.7 million job openings on the last business day of September, according to the Labor Department.

NWFA Approves Vermeister Finish Products   Full Article
St. Louis, MO, Nov. 13, 2014 -- The National Wood Flooring Association said that Vermeister S.p.A. has been approved for the NWFA Accepted Product Seal and NWFA Accepted Eco Product Seal designations.

Dixie Discontinuing Carousel Custom Line   Full Article
Chattanooga, TN, Nov. 13, 2014 -- The Dixie Group said it will discontinue its Carousel custom manufacturing line.

CRI Outlines 2015 Initiatives at Annual Meeting   Full Article
Dalton, GA, Nov. 13, 2014 -- The Carpet and Rug Institute (CRI) held its annual meeting in Dalton, Ga. yesterday.

Initial Jobless Claims Remain Below 300K   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 13, 2014 -- Initial jobless claims increased by 12,000 to 290,000 in the week ended Nov. 8, according to the Labor Department.

Resilient Institute Adds Seven New Members   Full Article
LaGrange, GA, Nov. 13, 2014 -- The Resilient Floor Covering Institute has expanded membership, adding four manufacturers and three suppliers to its roster.

Distributor Fishman Rolls Out Private Label Flooring   Full Article
Baltimore, MD, Nov. 13, 2014 -- Distributor Fishman Flooring Solutions said it is entering the private label flooring business.

Foreclosure Filings Spike in September   Full Article
Irvine, CA, Nov. 13, 2014 -- Foreclosure filings were reported on 123,109 properties in October, according to tracking firm RealtyTrac.

Wholesale Inventories Rise in September   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 12, 2014 -- U.S. wholesale inventories rose 0.3% in September after a 0.6% gain in August, according to the Commerce Department.

Beazer Homes Returns To Profit for Year   Full Article
Atlanta, GA, Nov. 12, 2014 -- Beazer Homes reported fiscal fourth-quarter net income of $59.8 million or $1.88 per share, compared to $11.9 million a year ago.

Mortgage Applications Fall Last Week   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 12, 2014 -- Applications for U.S. home mortgages fell last week as interest rates rose, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association.

NAFCD Names Award Winners   Full Article
Chicago, IL, Nov. 12, 2014 -- The North American Association of Floor Covering Distributors has named the winners of its Leadership in Action and Lifetime Achievement awards.

First TISE East Draws International Attendees   Full Article
Dallas, TX, Nov. 12, 2014 -- Hanley Wood Exhibitions said that its first-ever International Surface Event East featured 185 exhibiting companies covering over 50,000 square feet of booths and displays.

NAFCD Urges Members To Support Habitat Stores   Full Article
Chicago, IL, Nov. 11, 2014 -- The North American Association of Floor Covering Distributors Association is urging its members to support Habitat for Humanity's ReStores by donating materials and products.

Former Mannington VP Hollinger Dies   Full Article
Kennett Square, PA, Nov. 11, 2014 -- Mark A. Hollinger, age 58, a long-time Mannington Mills employee, died Nov. 5 after a year long battle with glioblastoma multiforme.

Desso Using Water Company Waste in Carpet Tile   Full Article
Waalwijk, The Netherlands, Nov. 11, 2014 -- Carpet company Desso said it is using chalk from local water companies to make its products.

Investment Adviser Reduces Stake in Armstrong   Full Article
Boston, MA, Nov. 11, 2014 -- Wellington Management Company of Boston has reduced its stake in Armstrong World Industries to less than 5% of the firm.

Mr. David's Founders Named Persons of Year   Full Article
Chicago, IL, Nov. 11, 2014 -- David and Leonard Zmijewski, the founders of Mr. David's Flooring International, have been named Persons of the Year by the Chicago Floor Covering Association.

Dover Rug & Home Wins Philanthropy Award   Full Article
Natick, MA, Nov. 10, 2014 -- Dover Rug & Home said it is the recipient of the 2014 Community Excellence Award, given by the Family Business Association of Massachusetts.

More Home Refinancers Taking Cash at Closing   Full Article
Washington, DC, Nov. 10, 2014 -- Borrowers cashed out an estimated $8 billion in home equity through refinancing of conventional mortgages in the third quarter, according to Freddie Mac’s quarterly refinancing report.